If you’re able to leave your calorie counting ways behind, then perhaps you could attempt to eat at Misty’s Diner. For those who are big fans of the Prahran store and live in the Northern Suburbs, you’d be pleased to know that Misty has opened another diner in Reservoir (of all places), you can find it on 765 Gilbert Rd, Reservoir- it’s closer to the Lake end of things.
I’m not sure how Misty(she is a real person and is very much American) decided that this particular location was THE location to have her second store. Nonetheless, it’s very hard for you to miss it.

You’ll definitely see the signage from a mileway however if you’re too busy driving and worried you might miss it, it’s opposite the 7-11 that’s on Gilbert Street.
When we went (which actually was last night, around 7pm), the place was very packed. Most of the tables were full and we worked out that you HAVE to go to the counter to order and pay (and someone brings the food to you)- it’s not a full table service.
The easiest thing to do (as we figured out quite quickly) was to grab a table, look at the menus (that are at the tables) and work out what we wanted and the other person go to order and the other sitting at the table minding it.
And so our food/drinks came out (if your drink is the standard in a can/bottle kind, once you pay for it, grab it from the fridge as they dont bring this to you, anything they have to make- they will bring to you)

Mr_54632 has an extremely sweet tooth and LOVES all kinds of sweet drinks/desserts. This was the “9 Candy Bar milkshake”. Basically lots of cream and actually a candy bar mixed in. So you’re drinking and crunching on chocolate… It was very YUM

The curly fries came out first WITHOUT our burgers. Curly fries are like normal fries except curly, they don’t taste any different and definitely not worth the $7.90 charge for them.


The burger with the egg was the “Misty’s American Style burger” and the other was the Double Whammy (2 lots of patties, 2 types of cheese, bbq sauce). I didn’t taste the American style burger but I can tell you that the egg was extremely yolky. My burger the double whammy- was extremely “saucey”. I could only finish 1/2 of my burger..it wasn’t bad, just that I was extremely FULL.
The burgers don’t actually come with any chips/ drinks and when you do a “combo”, it costs $7.90 extra for them
We didn’t think that the chips were going to be such large servings, but I guess when they cost that much, they gotta be.

Hence why we also ordered a serving of 1/2 (serving of)Taco chips. Technically the curly fries would have been enough. Of all the things we ate, I thoroughly enjoyed the taco chips which may look like a mess in the photo but it’s a combination of what you would find in a taco with mince meat. It was extremely tasty and frankly could have been a single standalone meal in itself. Next time, we’d forget the standard curly fries and order this instead.
I remember several years ago, when i was first introduced to Misty’s diner (and visited the Prahran one), I was severely disappointed- basically i found that the food to be a little bit too greasy, too many onions and found it overpriced. Years on- not much has changed, it is still a tad greasy and still very much overpriced. Our meal including a root beer that I haven’t taken a photo of (because its just a canned drink) came to a cost of $61.85. I’m not kidding. That’s a lot of money for some fries and 2 burgers. That’s several meals at Maccas for the both of us. If you’re after gourmet style burgers then this place isn’t for you. If you’re after greasy “american style burgers” and hot dogs and all things bad for you… then it’s worth a try.
And for a place that has approximately 40% rating on Urbanspoon, it’s doing a roaring trade, so clearly the people who go, LOVE it.
But the difference is, if you either live, work or hang around the area, you know that there isn’t exactly a LOT of choices when it comes to “restaurants” or “hangout with friends” area. And Misty’s diner is quite fun. The venue was filled with youthful looking people and NO families (well when we went there anyway) and I suspect that families wouldn’t even bother especially if meals cost that much.
It’s not to say there aren’t any mishaps. It took them a good 25 minutes for the burgers to arrive. I was starving by the time they came out (I know, I ate so little of it).
But I have to say, I was pretty impressed with the waitresses who brought the food out to the tables, they were quick to remove any plates/rubbish from the table as there’s a lot of it- ie. the wrapping from the burgers, the napkins used to wipe your face from the sauces. etc etc
Overall, we did enjoy the experience, the food wasn’t all bad even though I knew we overpaid. Would we be going back? We have to, apparently mr_54632 wants to try out their hot dogs… if it’s on him, then I wouldn’t have a problem going back






